Paul Ohm, a law professor at the University of Colorado, is arguing that ISP content filtering is a violation of the Federal Wiretap Statute. That’s a five-year felony sentence for the ISP, and perhaps for any ISP network administrators who actually set up and performed the monitoring, because the statute personal and corporate responsibility.
This seems like a steep price to pay for monitoring traffic, throttling P2P apps and serving up highly targeted advertisements on web pages, but AT&T, Charter and Comcast seem willing to take the risk. Perhaps they are betting on amnesty from President McCain.
Verizon hasn’t implemented content filtering because of the legal issues. Read this article on Wired for more information.
Will video kill broadband?
According to another Wired article, ISPs and telecoms are growing more concerned about IPTV — television over the internet — as a potential showstopper. Content filtering a la Charter and Comcast is a good example of bad blocking by ISPs. Demand for Internet video keeps rising while bandwidth growth hasn’t kept pace.
If ISPs do get to use deep packet inspection (DPI) to insert their own ads in web pages, Google and other web advertisers may retaliate by using SSL to encrypt their web pages. That prevents content filtering, but the cost in the server farm may be worth the effort for Google.
The rank-and-file residential user may not like a slower, encrypted search engine, however. Jakob Nielsen pointed out in this BBC article that Internet users are becoming more aware of latency and search accuracy. Users want faster, more relevant search results so they can go straight to a web page without visiting the target site’s home page first. Users have alredy learned to ignore banner ads, according to Nielsen’s discussion in this 20 June 2007 Wall Street Journal article. Content filtering won’t help matters.
Image courtesy of bryankennedy through a Creative Commons license.
Related posts on billso.com
- 14 April 2008: Virgin Media CEO claims net neutrality is “bollocks”
- 9 April 2008: The all-seeing advertising cookie
- 3 September 2007: When users block the ads, should web sites block the users?
- 19 March 2007: About e-commerce part 2: US ISPs sell web analytics data
- 28 July 2004: Stalking the P2P users
Comments on this entry are closed.