billso.com

Bill Sodeman writes about management, mobile computing and information systems

billso.com header image 4

The 700 mHz auction is over

ism tech

Posted Tuesday, 18 March 2008

Read 1 comment

As reported by the Associated Press, Reuters and two articles in today’s New York Times, the FCC’s auction for the 700 mHz spectrum has ended. The auction started in January, as I discussed in my 30 January 2008 article. The winners bid a combined total of US$19.59 billion.

The FCC is not dumb - buyers must pay in full. Their names will be released within the next 10 days.

Many other blogs are discussing this topic, including VentureBeat, CrunchGear, DailyWireless and PhoneScoop.

Tags: FCC, radio, spectrum, telecom, television, USA

Should Wikipedia include trivia?

7150 ism tech

Posted Tuesday, 18 March 2008

Wikipedia is a great place to look for a quick answer, but graduate students need to find credible sources for their papers. After all, graduate students are training to become credible sources in their fields.

The Economist published this article in the magazine’s Technology Quarterly supplement about Wikipedia’s editing policies. Two factions are battling for Wikipedia’s very soul:

  • Inclusionists want Wikipedia to have articles about any and every topic, with even the most trivial details of real and fictional items;
  • Deletionists want Wikipedia editors to exercise a more selective policy, which would require the deletion of many articles and trivial details.

A third moderate faction, the mergists, is seeking compromise. There are more details in the Wikipedia article on this inclusionism.

Nicholas Carr addressed this debate in his 5 September 2006 and and 8 September 2006 articles in his blog. Carr recommended “forking” Wikipedia into deletionist and inclusionist versions, which brings to mind visions of Unix. He also mentions the mergists and 18 other factions. Perhaps Monty Python should write a skit about Wikipedia.

This article by Nicholson Baker in the New York Review of Books has another perspective. Baker reviews Wikipedia: The Missing Manual, and Baker’s article is a long, funny look at how Wikipedia has evolved in the last 7 years.

Baker also includes a link to Reid Priedhorsky’s scholarly article on Wikipedia article creation and deletion.

Tags: authority, reliability, research, student, Wikipedia, writing